Teaching and Learning in Cyberspace: Promises and Perils in a DotCom World

Keynote for the Wisconsin Council of Teachers of English/Language Arts Fall Convention

October 14, 2005

Michael Day

View full text version


Abstract:
English and Language Arts teachers at all levels are feeling pressure from students, parents, and administrators to use advanced technologies such as the Internet in their classes.  Along with exploring some of the major possibilities and benefits of online activities in education, this keynote address will end on a cautionary note by asking educators to consider some of the dangers and drawbacks of cyberspace before taking students online.


Prologue: What we’re doing here.

What ARE we doing here???

Link to the WCTELA Fall Conference Program
URL for full text verssion of this talk:  http://www.engl.niu.edu/mday/wctela.html


Introduction: The World Wide Wastebasket
On the Internet, nobody knows you’re a dog 
"The Internet Produces a Global Village of Village Idiots" by Richard John Neuhaus
 The Virtual Community: Homesteading on the Electronic Frontier by Howard Rheingold

Promise: Using the web for gathering information
Sites of the eccentric and arcane:
Camembert Cheese
Collecting vintage slot machines

 
Electronic books

Peril: Protecting students from the worst of the web
NetNanny
Cybersitter


Peril: Plagiarism and copyright violations
An article about the extent of cheating
A site about Internet plagiarism,
A funny example of one of the sites from which students can buy papers on the web

Lawrence Lessig's remix culture

Digital Millennium Copyright Act
TEACH Act
Lawrence Lessig's site
Copyleft movement advocated by the Free Software Foundation


Promise: A public space for student work
Nancy Patterson’s eighth grade language arts classes at Portland Middle School
Ted Nellen’s cyberscholars

Promise or Peril: What is writing, anyway, in the age of the Internet?
Lawrence Lessig's remix culture
Kathleen Blake Yancey's 2004 CCCC Chair's Address
Peril leads to Promise: Sorting through the dreck and paying attention to trends
Michael Day's Evaluating Webbed Resources for Research
Michigan State University Six Tickets to Web Evaluation Site
Technology and Literacy in the Twenty-First Century: The Importance of Paying Attention by Cynthia Selfe

Promise: E-mail encourages more writing and different social relationships
Rush Limbaugh met his wife on Compuserve!

Promise: Making use of the living database of experts on the Internet
Howard Rheingold's Grassroots Groupminds
"Writing in the Matrix: Students Tapping the Living Database on the Computer Network" by Michael Day

Promise: Publishing for the people!
Blogger.com
Technorati
"Into the Blogosphere"

Peril: Who cares?

A post by CJ Jeney to the TechRhet discussion group, October 2002:

The awful, terrible, mind-sucking truth...
Is that nobody out there wants to read student web pages. Nobody except the author and the teacher. Anyone who goes around surfing [student] assigned webs is either an undergrad who has to do it for an assignment, or a teacher who is getting paid to do it for one reason or anther (i.e., teaching, evaluating, giving one of those warm-fuzzy 'awards').
 
They can do webs on September 11, or pets, or A Clockwork Orange, or Yoga, or Wicca Covens I Have Known, or Marilyn Manson Lyrics Deconstructed -- whatever. Nobody's reading them, nobody wants to, why should they?

 

Might as well take their codex papers and tack them to telephone poles: as many people would read those as are reading their webs.
 

It's a conceit, a construct, a space and place for writing, and for creating video/audio "cool stuff" that is only cool for a moment, and then nobody cares

Peril: Too many people care!
"Facebook: A Little Too Much Out There"

Promise: Basic instruction in netiquette teaches online communication conventions
Albion.com's Netiquette Home Page

Peril: Spam, scams, hoaxes and phishes!
Gratuitous Image of Pink Gelatinous Meat
Phishing for dollerz
Snopes.com: Rumor has it

Promise: New input systems can teach us new ways to think about writing
Voice recognition input systems
Deadalus Integrated Writing Environment 
The Network-Based Writing Classroom: The ENFI Idea by Trent Batson and Michael Day

Peril: Instant Messenger shortcuts bleed into academic writing
"Nu Shortcuts in School R 2 Much 4 Teachers" 

Promise: Planning for the new Internet and new Internet devices

Digital Convergency in a tiny package?  Repetitive Thumb Stress Injuries!
T-Mobile Sidekick
Samsung Palm-based PDA Phone
Motorola iTunes Rokr Cell Phone
 

Promise: If you email me, I will email you back!



Created by Michael Day
October 12, 2005
e-mail me!